Are CEOs a Dime a Dozen or Worth Their Weight in Gold?

In recent years, there has been considerable criticism of the amount of money that CEOs earn to run the largest U.S. companies. Governance researchers have expended considerable resources examining executive compensation in an effort to determine whether pay levels are set fairly. The results of these studies are generally mixed.

An important and related question, however, is rarely asked: Just how scarce is CEO talent? How many people are very well qualified to run a large, publicly traded company? These questions have important implications for CEO pay levels, performance measurement, succession planning, and internal talent development.

CEO Talent Pool

Recently, … Read more

Gadflies at the Gate: Why Do Individual Investors Sponsor Proxy Resolutions?

Individual investors are active participants in the shareholder resolution process. According to Proxy Monitor, shareholder proposals sponsored by individual investors represent approximately one-quarter of the total number of shareholder resolutions voted on each year.[1] During the 10-year period 2006-2015, individual investors brought forth over 1,100 resolutions at Fortune 500 companies. These resolutions span a vast array of topics, including proposed changes to board structure, executive compensation, shareholder rights, and corporate social policy (see Figure 1). [2]

larcker4

Figure 1: Individual Shareholder Resolutions, per Company (2006-2015)

Individual activism is a controversial topic. Critics contend that the large number of proposals filed … Read more

CEO Pay, Performance, and Value Sharing

We recently published a paper on CEO compensation and value sharing between executives and shareholders. The paper is available here.

CEO compensation is a controversial subject that evokes considerable debate on whether public company CEOs are paid correctly relative to corporate performance. A recent survey by Heidrick & Struggles and the Rock Center for Corporate Governance highlights the extreme disconnect between public perception of CEO pay and the perception of directors responsible for designing pay packages at Fortune 500 companies. While 65 percent of directors believe that CEO pay is not a problem, a full 70 percent of the … Read more

What Can For-Profit and Nonprofit Boards Learn from Each Other?

We recently published a paper on lessons that for-profit and nonprofit directors can learn from one another about improving organizational governance. The full paper is available here.

For-profit and nonprofit organizations exist for different reasons: for-profits to generate a return on investment for shareholders and nonprofits to pursue charitable and social activities unrelated to commerce. The obligations of the boards of both entities, however, are similar. Both are responsible for oversight of the organization, including reviewing strategy, finances, and performance. Both are also responsible for hiring and firing the CEO (or executive director), evaluating performance, and setting compensation. They … Read more

The Ideal Proxy Statement

We recently published a study (“2015 Investor Survey: Deconstructing Proxy Statements”) in collaboration with RR Donnelley and Equilar that examines how institutional investors use the information in corporate proxies to make voting and investment decisions. Full results are available here.[1]

We find that institutional investors are highly dissatisfied with the quality of information that they receive about corporate governance policies and practices in the annual proxy. Across the board, investors want proxies to be shorter, more concise, more candid, and less legal. Fifty-five percent of investors believe that the typical proxy statement is too long. Forty-eight percent believe … Read more

Professional Coaching and Advising of Senior Executives

Professor David Larcker is Morgan Stanley Director of the Center for Leadership Development and Research at the Stanford Graduate School of Business.  Brian Tayan is a researcher in the center.  They are co-authors of the book A Real Look at Real World Corporate Governance.

There is very little discussion in the research literature about the professional coaching and advising of senior executives at the very top of organizations. We conducted our survey to help fill this gap with descriptive information that provides the basis for careful thinking about coaching.

We find that approximately one in three CEOs receives coaching or … Read more